Decision 0351Ha – California State University (Statewide University Police Association)
LA-UM-252-H (LA-HR-8)
Decision Date: May 30, 1984
Decision Type: PERB Decision
Perc Vol: 8
Perc Index: 15097
Decision Headnotes
1107.10000 – Request for Reconsideration
Reconsideration means to review a previous matter implies that the same body that first issued the decision would review it and rule again. Request for reconsideration does not include right to reexamination by other than original panel of Board.
1309.13000 – Supervisors
Determination of lack of supervisory status based upon totality of evidence presented. Sergeants did not possess or exercise independent judgment when administering disciplinary action, but rather ordered in accordance with the superior's opinion. Including 59 contested positions would have resulted in 100 persons supervising 197 non-supervisors, sufficient distinction from Grayhound case (NLRB) where 121 dispatchers supervised 3,000 drivers, to hold different conclusion. Mere potential to resolve informal grievances, is insufficient to support finding of supervisory status, and evidence showed day-to-day disputes were reconciled by sergeants, not as agents for the employer, but as co-workers concerned with reducing disruption of the work environment. MOU between the parties does not make sergeants but as co-workers concerned with reducing disruption of the work environment. MOU between the parties does not make sergeants
1309.09000 – Law Enforcement
Determination of lack of supervisory status based upon totality of evidence presented. Sergeants did not possess or exercise independent judgment when administering disciplinary action, but rather ordered in accordance with the superior's opinion. Including 59 contested positions would have resulted in 100 persons supervising 197 non-supervisors, sufficient distinction from Greyhound case (NLRB) where 121 dispatchers supervised 3,000 drivers, to hold different conclusion. Mere potential to resolve informal grievances, is insufficient to support finding of supervisory status, and evidence showed day-to-day disputes were reconciled by sergeants, not as agents for the employer, but as co-workers concerned with reducing disruption of the work environment. MOU between the parties does not make sergeants but as co-workers concerned with reducing disruption of the work environment. MOU between the parties does not make sergeants
1310.02000 – Change in Circumstances
MOU between the parties does not make sergeants supervisory nor does it override decision made by the Board.
1311.01000 – In General
Board declines to join in request for judicial review where request is not more than disagreement with Board's decision and Board believes its decision is well-founded.
1503.02000 – Regulations Considered (By Number)
32410(a) - dosen't contemplate the parties determining which Board member will decide the request for reconsideration. 32500(c) - Board declines to join request for judicial review.
200.04000 – Supervisors
Determination of lack of supervisory status based upon totality of evidence presented. Sergeants did not possess or exercise independent judgment when administering disciplinary action, but rather ordered in accordance with the superior's opinion. Including 59 contested positions would have resulted in 100 persons supervising 197 non-supervisors, sufficient distinction from Greyhound case (NLRB) where 121 dispatchers supervised 3,000 drivers, to hold different conclusion. Mere potential to resolve informal grievances, is insufficient to support finding of supervisory status, and evidence showed day-to-day disputes were reconciled by sergeants, not as agents for the employer, but as co-workers concerned with reducing disruption of the work environment. MOU between the parties does not make sergeants but as co-workers concerned with reducing disruption of the work environment. MOU between the parties does not make sergeants