Decision 2876Ma – County of Santa Clara
SF-CE-1796-M
Decision Date: November 16, 2026
Decision Type: PERB Decision
Description: The complaint alleged that County of Santa Clara violated its bargaining obligations to Registered Nurses Professional Association and Service Employees International Union Local 521 when it responded to COVID-19 by changing policies and assignments without affording the unions adequate notice and opportunity to bargain over the County’s decisions and/or their negotiable effects. The ALJ’s proposed decision concluded that even though the pandemic qualified as an emergency, the County nonetheless violated its bargaining obligations. The parties filed cross-exceptions. In County of Santa Clara (2023) PERB Decision No. 2876-M, the Board held that: (1) the County could take necessary measures to save lives without first reaching an impasse or agreement, though it had a duty to afford the unions notice and an opportunity to bargain in good faith to the extent practicable under the circumstances; and (2) the County failed to comply with this duty. The County filed a writ petition with the California Court of Appeal, and the court issued an unpublished opinion and order annulling the Board’s decision and remanding for further proceedings.
Disposition: Pursuant to the court’s order, the Board vacated its prior decision and replaced it with a new precedential decision, finding as follows. The County had no duty to bargain over its decision to declare an emergency or its decision to deploy represented employees as disaster service workers in response to that emergency. However, the County did have a duty to bargain as practicable over: (1) terms and conditions of employment for represented employees deployed to private nursing facilities and motels—including their selection, safety protections, workload, and compensation; (2) new and amended disaster service policies; and (3) effects of the County’s decision to scale back services at its medical clinics. Because the COVID-19 pandemic presented a true emergency, the County’s bargaining duty did not include a requirement for it to reach impasse or agreement before implementing the new assignments and policies. Rather, the County had to bargain as practicable. The County did not comply with this duty.
Decision Headnotes