Decision 2958Ma – City and County of San Francisco
SF-CE-2157-M
Decision Date: November 20, 2026
Decision Type: PERB Decision
Description: This case came before the Board for a second time. The operative facts arose while Charging Party Municipal Attorneys Association of San Francisco (MAA) was negotiating for a new MOU with Respondent City and County of San Francisco. MAA proposed MOU language that would require the City to show just cause for terminating MAA-represented attorneys and would further require that attorney layoffs proceed in reverse-seniority order. The City acknowledged that the job protection proposals involved mandatory subjects of bargaining under the MMBA, but refused to agree to the proposals and refused to submit the bargaining impasse to binding interest arbitration under the impasse resolution procedures set forth is the San Francisco City Charter. In City and County of San Francisco (2025) PERB Decision No. 2958-M, the Board found that: (1) the Charter affords MAA the right to engage in interest arbitration over its job protection proposals; and (2) the City violated the Charter and the MMBA when it refused to submit the bargaining impasse to interest arbitration. Thereafter, the City filed a petition for extraordinary writ with the California Court of Appeal, and the court vacated the Board’s decision. (City and County of San Francisco v. Public Employment Relations Bd. (2026) 121 Cal.App.5th 243, 253 & 269 [upholding the City’s position that MAA’s proposals are subject to bargaining and advisory factfinding under the MMBA but not interest arbitration under the Charter].)
Disposition: In accordance with the appellate decision, the Board dismissed the matter.
Decision Headnotes