PARTIES; DEFINITIONS; WHO IS AN EMPLOYEE? (SEE 502 AND 1309) – Managerial and Confidential

Single Topic for Decision 2203M

View all topics for Decision 2203M

Full Decision Text (click on the link to view): Full Text

200.02000 – Managerial and Confidential

The MMBA covers all levels of employees except elected officials and gubernatorial appointees. It neither defines "supervisor" nor precludes the formation of a bargaining unit that includes both supervisory and non-supervisory employees. As stated in Organization of Deputy Sheriffs v. County of San Mateo (1975) 48 Cal.App.3d 331, 338, the MMBA confers organizational and representational rights on supervisory, management and confidential employees "without regard to their position in the administrative hierarchy.” In Santa Clara County Counsel Attorneys Assn. v. Woodside (1994) 7 Cal.4th 525, the Supreme Court observed: “By choosing to explicitly include supervisorial, managerial, and confidential employees within the realm of the MMBA's protections, the Legislature implicitly decided that the benefits for public sector labor relations achieved by including managerial employees outweighed the potential divided loyalty dilemmas raised. We therefore note at the outset that any argument which contends that MMBA protections should not apply to certain managerial employees because of problems with divided loyalty must be viewed with skepticism, for that argument follows precisely the legislative road the MMBA declined to take.” (Id. at p. 538; fn. omitted.) Board found no basis to exclude Leads from a unit based solely on their leadership roles. Where Leads spend at least ten percent of their time regularly performing the same kind of maintenance work and using the same tools as their crews, it does not matter that their supervision responsibilities are distinctive. Board also noted that Leads: share a common goal with other employees (to ensure that City facilities are well maintained); have daily contact with one another; and share similar training, qualifications, and skills, mainly that learned working in the field.