Decision 0329H – Regents of the University of California, University of California Los Angeles Medical Center
LA-CE-1-H
Decision Date: August 5, 1983
Decision Type: PERB Decision
Perc Vol: 7
Perc Index: 14214
Decision Headnotes
401.01000 – In General; Prima Facie Case.
Employer's rules restricting access to areas within the acute care hospital are reviewed, some upheld and others rejected. Test of balancing justifiable concerns and avoiding overbroad, unnecessary interference with statutory rights. HEERA provides to employee organization representatives, employee and nonemployee alike, a presumptive right to access to employees at reasonable times in areas where they work; p. 6. Presumptive right can be rebutted by evidence that a ban on access is necessary to prevent disruption of health care operations or disturbance of patients. Employee lounges, locker rooms and classrooms are not immediate patient care areas, and are legitimate avenues of access. Exceptions discussed including employer's right to make reasonable precautions to prevent spreading infections. Employer carries burden of proving disruption would occur. Availability of alternative access is important factor to infections. Employer carries burden of proving disruption would occur. Availability of alternative access is important factor to with right of employees who wish to participate in employee organization activities; p. 17.
101.03000 – NLRA/LMRDA Precedent
Presumptive right of access of employee organization representatives to non-immediate patient care areas found in HEERA similar to NLRA precedent; p. 6.
401.03000 – Ban on Distribution or Solicitation
Employer's rules restricting access to areas within the acute care hospital are reviewed, some upheld and others rejected. Test of balancing justifiable concerns and avoiding overbroad, unnecessary interference with statutory rights. HEERA provides to employee organization representatives, employee and nonemployee alike, a presumptive right of access to employees at reasonable times in areas where they work; p. 6. Presumptive right can be rebutted by evidence that a ban on access is necessary to prevent disruption of health care operations or disturbance of patients. Employee lounges, locker rooms and classrooms are not immediate patient care areas, and are legitimate avenues of access. Exceptions discussed including employer's right to make reasonable precautions to prevent spreading infections. Employer carries burden of proving disruption would occur. Availability of alternative access is important factor to infections. Employer carries burden of proving disruption would occur. Availability of alternative access is important factor to
401.04000 – Access – Union Right
Employer's rules restricting access to areas within the acute care hospital are reviewed, some upheld and others rejected. Test of balancing justifiable concerns and avoiding overbroad, unnecessary interference with statutory rights. HEERA provides to employee organization representatives, employee and nonemployee alike, a presumptive right of access to employees at reasonable times in areas where they work; p. 6. Presumptive right can be rebutted by evidence that a ban on access is necessary to prevent disruption of health care operations or disturbance of patients. Employee lounges, locker rooms and classrooms are not immediate patient care areas, and are legitimate avenues of access. Exceptions discussed including employer's right to make reasonable precautions to prevent spreading infections. Employer carries burden of proving disruption would occur. Availability of alernative access is important factor to infections. Employer carries burden of proving disruption would occur. Availability of alernative access is important factor to with right of employees who wish to participate in employee organization activities; p. 17.
1105.07000 – Administrative and Judicial Notice
Board exercises discretion in taking notice of materials filed by parties in Superior court action. Board won't take notice where nothing of probative value added.
1107.13000 – Administrative and Judicial Notice
Board exercises discretion in taking notice of materials filed by parties in Superior Court action. Board won't take notice where nothing of prolative value added.